'Der Besuch der alten Dame' – A Comprehensive A-Level German Study Guide

Introduction

Friedrich Dürrenmatt’s Der Besuch der alten Dame (The Visit) is a seminal Swiss play first performed in 1956. Often classified as a tragicomedy, it explores timeless themes of justice, morality, vengeance, and the corrosive influence of wealth. The play has been studied by generations of A-level German students for its rich content and thought-provoking message. This guide provides a holistic overview of the play, including its plot, characters, main themes, key messages, and enduring relevance. German quotations from the text are included (with English translations) to illustrate important points, and we conclude with advice on tackling common exam questions about the play.

Picture by Werner Kmetisch taken from https://www.faz.net/aktuell/feuilleton/buehne-und-konzert/duerrenmatts-komoedie-der-besuch-der-alten-dame-als-oper-15500619.html

🇩🇪 Ready to excel in A-level German? Our weekly classes, private tuition, and intensive revision courses cover everything from grammar to essay writing. Ideal for both school students and external candidates aiming for an A*.

A-Level German tuition in London and online

All You Need to Know about Der Besuch der alten Dame

Plot Overview

Claire Zachanassian, the world’s wealthiest woman, returns to her impoverished hometown of Güllen after many decades in search of justice. Güllen (a name meaning “liquid manure”) once prided itself on its cultural and humanistic tradition but has fallen into dire economic ruin. The townspeople eagerly welcome Claire, hoping she will donate some of her fortune to revive the town’s economy. However, Claire’s homecoming is not a charitable visit – it is a reckoning born of revenge. She makes a shocking offer: “Ich gebe euch eine Milliarde und kaufe mir dafür die Gerechtigkeit” (Claire: “I will give you one billion and buy myself justice for it”). In exchange for a donation of one billion (half to the town, half to its families), Claire demands the execution of Alfred Ill, the town’s shopkeeper and her former lover who betrayed her in their youth.

Initially, the town of Güllen – led by the Mayor – rejects Claire’s gruesome proposal. “Ich lehne im Namen der Stadt Güllen das Angebot ab. Im Namen der Menschlichkeit. Lieber bleiben wir arm denn blutbefleckt.” (Bürgermeister: “I reject the offer in the name of the town of Güllen. In the name of humanity. We’d rather remain poor than stained with blood.”). This stirring declaration of morality even earns “riesigen Beifall” (thunderous applause) from the townspeople. Claire’s curt response to their moral stance is simply, “Ich warte.” (“I’ll wait.”). And indeed, as the plot unfolds, Claire patiently waits as the desperation of the townspeople grows and their principles begin to waver.

Over the course of the three-act play, the seemingly principled citizens of Güllen gradually yield to temptation. At first, they continue professing that “justice cannot be bought.” “Die Gerechtigkeit kann man doch nicht kaufen!” (Bürgermeister: “You can’t buy justice!”) – to which Claire coldly retorts, “Man kann alles kaufen.” (“One can buy anything.”). Soon, subtle changes in the town’s atmosphere hint at a collective change of heart. The townspeople start purchasing expensive items on credit, and bright new gelbe Schuhe (yellow shoes) and other luxuries appear, even though no money has yet been received. These yellow shoes become a visible symbol of Güllen’s moral decay – a sign that the people already anticipate Ill’s death and the wealth it will bring. Alfred III grows increasingly fearful as he realises that his neighbours–even his family–are preparing to kill him for Claire’s reward. All of Ill’s attempts to find help fail: the police officer, the pastor, and even the town mayor give him empty reassurances while joining the others in buying new goods. Ill’s panic peaks when he tries to flee, but the townspeople prevent his escape, solidifying his doom.

In the climactic town meeting, the schoolmaster (Lehrer) – the last voice of conscience – delivers a drunken plea to uphold humanist values, only to conclude in despair: “Auch ich werde mitmachen. Ich fühle, wie ich langsam zu einem Mörder werde… Mein Glaube an die Humanität ist machtlos.” (Lehrer: “I, too, will take part. I feel how I am slowly becoming a murderer… My faith in humanity is powerless.”). Ultimately, the community’s vote is unanimous: they resolve to execute Alfred Ill under the pretence of justice for Claire. Surrounded by the townspeople, Ill accepts his fate and is killed – a death later reported to the press as an “accident” or the result of Ill’s “joy” at the town’s newfound prosperity. Claire has finally obtained her ruthless form of “justice” and leaves Güllen with Ill’s coffin, as the town celebrates the promise of wealth. The tragedy lies in the collective moral downfall: the citizens of Güllen sacrifice their integrity and become complicit in murder for the sake of financial salvation.

Tip: Write an interpretive summary that covers main points of the plot, focusing on Claire's return to her hometown, her proposal to the townspeople, and the moral dilemma faced by the community.

Character Analysis

Claire Zachanassian – The Wealthy Avenger

Claire Zachanassian (born Klara Wäscher) is the central figure driving the play’s conflict. Once a naive young woman in love with Alfred Ill, she was betrayed by him – he denied paternity of her child and bribed false witnesses to win the court case, leading to her disgrace and exile from Güllen. Decades later, Claire returns as a fantastically wealthy Witwe (widow) with a prosthetic leg and hand, and even an entourage of odd companions (including two eunuchs and a pet panther). These grotesque details about her character (her artificial limbs and pet panther) highlight that Claire has been fundamentally shaped by trauma, and perhaps lost some of her humanity along the way.

Claire embodies both victim and villain. On one hand, she is a tragic figure: life made her suffer terribly (she endured poverty, prostitution, loss of her child, and a string of disastrous marriages). She pointedly tells the townspeople, “Die Welt machte mich zu einer Hure, nun mache ich sie zu einem Bordell.” (“The world turned me into a whore, now I turn it into a brothel.”). With this blunt metaphor, Claire suggests that the world forced her into selling herself (as a prostitute after Ill abandoned her), and now she will expose the world’s corruption by buying indulgence for murder. The line drips with bitterness and irony: Claire sees society’s morals as purchasable commodities, just as her own dignity was once sold.

Despite her pitiless actions, Claire’s character also evokes a degree of sympathy. She has been deeply scarred by Ill’s betrayal and the town’s complicity in her humiliation. In Claire’s view, her offer to Güllen is poetic justice – a chance to balance the scales by exchanging money for the life of the man who wronged her.

Claire’s power lies in her immense wealth and her unyielding will. She orchestrates the entire scheme with confident patience, fully expecting that no one can resist financial temptation forever. Notably, she often behaves with a detached, dark humour, as if the whole affair were a theatrical performance. For instance, Claire arrives in Güllen with a pet panther, which later escapes and is shot dead, foreshadowing Ill’s fate. Claire shows no emotion at the panther’s death, remarking that it was “the fate of all pets in Güllen,” indirectly hinting at Ill’s looming end. Throughout the play, Claire remains in control: she has even “purchased” key figures from her past (the false witnesses who are now her eunuchs, and the judge who once ruled against her now employed as her butler) to publicly lay out Ill’s wrongdoing. By the final act, Claire has effectively bought the town’s soul to get her revenge.

Claire is a complex and enigmatic character. Her return to Güllen is driven by a desire for revenge, and her character embodies the consequences of a life marked by betrayal and loss. Her wealth becomes a symbol of both power and tragedy.

Tip: Explore her motivations, her tragic past, and her transformation into a symbol of justice and vengeance.

Symbol of Vengeance and Justice

• Claire serves as a powerful symbol of both vengeance and justice in the play. Her return to Güllen is driven by a desire for revenge against Alfred Ill, who wronged her in their youth. However, her pursuit of justice is deeply entangled with a thirst for retribution, challenging conventional notions of right and wrong.

Complexity of Character

• Claire's character is marked by complexity and ambiguity. While she embodies the victim seeking retribution, her methods and the moral dilemmas she presents to the townspeople raise questions about the nature of her justice. Dürrenmatt presents Claire as a multi-dimensional character, inviting the audience to grapple with the complexities of her motivations.

Wealth as Empowerment

• Claire's immense wealth becomes a tool of empowerment, both for herself and as a means to manipulate others. Her financial resources enable her to orchestrate a situation where the townspeople must confront their own moral compromises. The play explores the extent to which wealth can grant agency and influence over others.

Tragic Figure

• Despite her formidable presence and the aura of vengeance surrounding her, Claire is portrayed as a tragic figure. Her past traumas, including her failed relationships and the loss of her child, contribute to a sense of sympathy for her character. The tragedy lies not only in her quest for revenge but in the personal suffering that underlies it.

Catalyst for Moral Dilemma

• Claire's arrival serves as a catalyst for a profound moral dilemma within the town. The offer of wealth in exchange for Alfred Ill's life forces the townspeople to confront their own values and priorities. Claire's presence exposes the vulnerabilities and weaknesses in the moral fabric of Güllen.

Psychological Depth

• Dürrenmatt invests Claire with psychological depth, providing insights into her psyche and the lasting impact of her past experiences. Her ill-fated relationships and the emotional scars she carries contribute to a nuanced portrayal. Claire's character invites reflection on the enduring effects of personal tragedy and the complexities of human emotions.

Symbol of External Influence

• Claire's return to Güllen represents the intrusion of external forces into the town's insular existence. Her wealth and vendetta represent broader societal issues and the potential consequences of actions that transcend individual lives. Claire becomes a metaphor for the external pressures that can shape the destiny of a community.

Irony and Absurdity

• The irony and absurdity surrounding Claire's revenge plan add layers of complexity to her character. The extravagant nature of her offer and the theatricality of her presence contribute to the play's tragicomic tone. Claire's actions challenge traditional expectations, underscoring the unpredictability of human behaviour.

Reflection on Morality

• Claire's character prompts a profound reflection on morality, justice, and the limits of revenge. Her role in the play invites the audience to question the fine line between justice and vengeance and consider the moral compromises individuals may make in the pursuit of personal vindication.

Dürrenmatt's portrayal of Claire transcends simplistic categorisations, presenting her as a tragic figure whose presence challenges the moral fabric of the town and prompts deep introspection on the nature of justice and morality.

Alfred Ill – The Marked Man

Alfred Ill is Güllen’s beloved shopkeeper and the man who once jilted Claire. At the start of the play, Ill is confident that the townsfolk will support him – he is popular and expected to be the next mayor. However, as Claire announces her deadly proposal, Ill undergoes a dramatic transformation from respectable citizen to tragic victim. It is gradually revealed that Ill did indeed ruin Claire’s life out of cowardice and greed. He fears justice catching up to him, and with good reason: the town’s facade of loyalty crumbles as everyone starts buying on credit, clearly planning to earn the bounty on Ill’s head.

Ill’s journey is at the heart of the play’s tragic arc. He moves through denial, panic, and finally resignation. In Act II, Ill becomes paranoid and desperate when he notices new purchases around town (the new yellow shoes, for example, which signify the town’s quiet decision to kill him). He confronts the townspeople, but they respond with hypocritical reassurances and quotes of lofty poetry, refusing to admit their intentions. One striking moment is when Ill runs to the police station, only for the policeman to subtly threaten him instead; even the church offers no refuge. By Act III, Ill accepts the inevitable. He tells the schoolmaster and the pastor that he will not flee: “Ich kämpfe nicht mehr.” (“I won’t fight anymore.”) and “Es ist alles meine Tat… Ich kann mir nicht mehr helfen und euch auch nicht mehr.” (“All of this is my doing… I can no longer help myself, nor any of you.”). Ill recognizes his guilt in causing Claire’s transformation (“Ich habe Klara zu dem gemacht, was sie ist” – “I made Klara into what she is,” he admits) and understands that he must pay for that guilt. In his final moments, Ill regains a measure of dignity by accepting responsibility, standing bravely as the town closes in to kill him.

Throughout the play, Alfred Ill can be seen as an everyman figure whose personal failings reflect a broader human weakness. He is neither a noble hero nor a purely evil villain – rather, he is an ordinary man who once chose selfish gain over love and justice, and now faces the consequences. Ill’s tragic fate elicits pity and fear in the classical sense, but Dürrenmatt overlays this with irony. It is ironic that Ill, once the most esteemed citizen of Güllen, becomes a sacrifice to the town’s welfare; ironic that his name “Ill” signals his ill-fate; and ironic that his death is collectively carried out by the very people who once respected him. In the end, Ill’s character serves as a cautionary example of how personal guilt and societal complicity intertwine.

Alfred Ill

Alfred Ill is the tragic figure at the centre of Claire's vendetta. His moral decline and the revelation of his past actions contribute to the play's exploration of guilt and accountability. As the townspeople grapple with Claire's offer, Alfred becomes a representation of the human capacity for self-deception.

Tip: Analyse his character, his role in Claire's past, and his moral dilemma.

Tragic Hero

• Alfred Ill functions as a tragic hero in the play. His past actions, specifically his betrayal of Claire, come back to haunt him, leading to his tragic downfall. Ill's character embodies the classical archetype of a flawed protagonist whose actions contribute to his own undoing.

Moral Dilemma

• Ill is thrust into a profound moral dilemma when faced with Claire's offer. The prospect of immense wealth in exchange for his own moral compromise forces him to confront the consequences of his past actions. His internal struggle becomes a focal point of the play, highlighting the complexities of ethical decision-making.

Corruption by Wealth

• Alfred Ill's character illustrates the corrupting influence of wealth. As the promise of financial prosperity dangles before him, Ill succumbs to the temptation, abandoning his moral principles. The transformation of Ill from a respected figure to a morally compromised individual serves as a cautionary tale about the corrupting power of financial incentives.

Symbol of the Town's Moral Decay

• Ill becomes a symbol of the town's moral decay as he leads the community into a collective compromise. His actions and decisions, particularly in his role as the mayor, contribute to the erosion of ethical standards within Güllen. Ill's personal downfall mirrors the broader societal consequences of prioritising wealth over morality.

Irony in Ill's Fate

• The irony in Ill's fate is a significant aspect of his role. As the town's respected figure, Ill is initially oblivious to the consequences of his past actions. However, the ironic twists of the plot reveal the tragic inevitability of his downfall. The very qualities that once elevated him in the eyes of the community become the catalysts for his undoing.

Reflection of Societal Values

• Ill's character reflects the societal values of Güllen. His initial status as a well-regarded figure represents the town's collective identity. However, as he succumbs to the allure of wealth, Ill mirrors the moral compromises made by the community at large. His journey becomes emblematic of broader societal tendencies and vulnerabilities.

Psychological Complexity

• Dürrenmatt endows Ill with psychological complexity. The internal conflict and emotional turmoil experienced by Ill as he grapples with Claire's offer add depth to his character. Ill's psychological journey becomes a microcosm of the town's struggles with morality, justice, and the corrupting influence of wealth.

  
  

Tragicomic Element

• The character of Ill contributes to the tragicomic element of the play. His predicament, while tragic, is marked by absurdity and irony. The audience is compelled to both sympathise with his internal struggles and acknowledge the humour inherent in the absurdity of the situation.

Symbol of Human Frailty

• Alfred Ill depicts the inherent frailty of human nature. His moral lapses and vulnerability to external pressures underscore the universal theme of the potential for individuals to compromise their principles when faced with personal gain. Ill's character transcends the specific context of Güllen, offering a broader commentary on human fallibility.

Ill plays a pivotal role as the tragic hero whose actions and moral compromises contribute to the play's exploration of justice, morality, and the corrupting influence of wealth. His character serves as a lens through which the audience witnesses the internal and external struggles emblematic of broader societal challenges and human vulnerabilities.

The Townspeople of Güllen – A Collective Character

The population of Güllen (often referred to collectively as “die Güllener”) functions almost as a single character in the play, representing collective behavior and morality. Initially, the Gülleners present themselves as upright, cultured, and unified in virtuous poverty. They celebrate their town’s humanist values and cheer the Mayor’s refusal of Claire’s offer. However, Dürrenmatt gradually peels back this veneer of moral integrity to expose deep hypocrisy and weakness. The town’s decline into greed is comically and tragically portrayed through their actions: they begin to justify the coming crime in indirect ways (for instance, the townspeople start speaking of “justice” for Claire and citing her suffering to rationalize their shift). By Act III, the townspeople have adopted a near-ceremonial tone about Ill’s impending death, referring to it as if it were a just and even religious act (there are parallels drawn to a sacrifice or a trial).

The schoolteacher and the pastor are two individuals who briefly struggle with their consciences, yet even they succumb. The Lehrer (teacher) in particular symbolises the failure of intellectual and ethical resistance: after trying to rouse the town’s principles, he admits his powerlessness and decides to join the mob. In a chilling line, the teacher tells Ill that he fears one day another old lady will arrive for them – implying that by murdering Ill, the townspeople are incurring a moral debt that will be repaid in kind. The broad participation of all layers of society – the police, clergy, shopkeepers, family members – in Ill’s murder shows how collective guilt is formed. Each person alone claims they wouldn’t harm Ill, yet together they enable and carry out the atrocity.

Dürrenmatt uses the townspeople as a vehicle for biting social commentary. Güllen becomes a microcosm of a society that prides itself on decency but is corrupted by the promise of wealth. The play suggests that even “good” people can commit terrible acts when the price is high enough. The gradual change in the town’s language and behavior masterfully illustrates how humans can rationalize immoral acts: at first with denial (“it’s just a hypothetical offer”), then with deflection (“Ill has wronged Claire, so justice is on her side”), and finally with collective resolve (“we must do this for the town’s future”). The townspeople’s arc from poverty with integrity to prosperity through crime is what makes Der Besuch der alten Dame so disturbing and thought-provoking.

The townspeople in the play represent a moral dilemma faced by society when dealing with the temptation of wealth. Their willingness to compromise their values for financial gain shows how communities can be vulnerable to outside influences. Their collective actions and responses mirror broader themes related to morality, justice, and the corrupting influence of wealth.

Collective Morality

• The townspeople collectively embody a particular moral code that is initially presented as upright and virtuous. However, this collective morality is tested when faced with the tempting offer of wealth from Claire. The town's initial moral stance undergoes a transformation, revealing the fragility of collective ethics in the face of personal gain.

Economic Desperation

• The economic struggles of the town contribute to the townspeople's vulnerability to Claire's offer. Güllen is depicted as a financially struggling community, and the prospect of Claire's wealth becomes a seductive solution to their economic woes. The townspeople's desperation becomes a driving force behind their moral compromise.

Reception of Claire's Offer

• Initially, the townspeople reject Claire Zachanassian's offer, reflecting a semblance of moral integrity. However, as the play progresses, the townspeople gradually succumb to the allure of wealth. The transformation in their attitudes highlights the malleability of collective morality and the impact of external pressures.

Betrayal and Compromise

• The townspeople ultimately betray their own moral principles. The willingness to compromise ethical values for personal gain becomes a collective decision, illustrating the corrosive effects of wealth on the town's moral fabric. The betrayal is both individual, as seen in Ill's actions, and collective, as the townspeople unite in their choice.

Social Commentary

• Dürrenmatt uses the townspeople as a vehicle for social commentary, critiquing societal values and the impact of economic disparities on collective morality. The play suggests that in the face of financial temptation, even a seemingly virtuous community can succumb to moral compromise, revealing underlying flaws in the social fabric.

Symbol of Human Frailty

• The townspeople collectively symbolise the frailty of human nature. The play explores the inherent vulnerability of individuals and communities when confronted with external pressures, especially those related to wealth and prosperity. The townspeople's actions serve as a cautionary tale about the potential erosion of moral principles.

Tragicomic Elements

• The townspeople contribute to the tragicomic elements of the play. The absurdity and irony arise from the stark contrast between the townspeople's initial rejection of Claire's offer and their eventual capitulation. The play's tone is both tragic, as it explores the consequences of moral compromise, and comic, as it highlights the absurdity of the human condition.

Role in the Town's Transformation

• The townspeople play a pivotal role in the transformation of Güllen. As they collectively embrace Claire's wealth, the town undergoes a radical change, both economically and morally. The townspeople's decisions drive the narrative toward its inevitable and tragic conclusion.

In the play, the townspeople collectively represent the moral conscience of the community. Their actions and choices underscore the play's exploration of justice, revenge, and the moral complexities that arise when faced with the seductive power of wealth.

Key Themes and Messages

The key themes of the play are justice, morality and the power of vengeance, the corruption of wealth, tragedy and comedy, and symbolism and imagery. In what follows, I will discuss each of the themes and highlight questions you may want to develop in your essay.

Justice Versus Vengeance

At its core, the play is an interrogation of justice: What is true justice, and can it be bought or perverted? Claire arrives in Güllen, declaring she wants “Gerechtigkeit” (justice) in exchange for her money. However, the justice she seeks is indistinguishable from revenge. Decades earlier, the legal system failed her – Ill’s lies triumphed over truth – so she now pursues vigilante justice by leveraging her wealth. This raises uncomfortable questions: Is it justifiable to take a life in exchange for personal gain, even if the person in question has committed a heinous act? Does righting an old wrong excuse committing a new one? The townspeople initially insist that murder for money is not justice at all, yet in the end they convince themselves that Claire’s cause makes it just. The line between justice and vengeance becomes dangerously blurred.

Dürrenmatt highlights this blurred line through Claire’s own words and the town’s ethical collapse. Claire’s famous declaration, “Die Gerechtigkeit kann man doch nicht kaufen! … Man kann alles kaufen.” – (Mayor: “But you can’t buy justice!” Claire: “One can buy anything.”) – underscores that in her worldview, morality has a price tag. The play demonstrates the commodification of justice: for a billion, the community adopts Claire’s personal vendetta as their collective notion of justice. Importantly, the audience is made to feel the irony and horror of this transaction. By the final scenes, the townspeople perform a grotesque semblance of a trial and conviction for Ill, as if to give their vengeance a legalistic guise. Dürrenmatt forces the audience to reflect on how easily “justice” can be twisted when personal gain is involved.

Ultimately, Der Besuch der alten Dame delivers a cynical but impactful message about justice: true justice is not achieved in Güllen. What occurs is Rache (revenge) masquerading as justice, which serves as a critique of both human nature and societal institutions. Yet the play’s ending also suggests that this false justice comes at a moral cost – the town has sold its soul, and everyone bears the guilt. In a broader sense, Dürrenmatt seems to warn that justice loses its meaning in a corrupt world, and that those who compromise their principles will face inescapable consequences. The play raises profound questions about justice and morality. Is it justifiable to take a life in exchange for personal gain, even if the person in question has committed a heinous act? The moral dilemma faced by the townspeople becomes a central theme.

Tip: Examine how the play raises questions about justice, morality, and the consequences of compromising principles for personal gain. Here are some key points to help you.

• One of the central themes of the play is the concept of justice and its transformation into vengeance. Claire Zachanassian's return to Güllen is driven by a desire for revenge, as she seeks justice for the wrongs she suffered in the past. However, as the narrative unfolds, the audience is compelled to question whether her pursuit aligns with conventional notions of justice or descends into a more sinister form of retribution.

• The play explores the moral compromises individuals are willing to make when faced with extreme circumstances. The townspeople, grappling with poverty and the promise of financial prosperity, face a collective moral dilemma. Their decisions to sacrifice justice for personal gain reveal the fragility of moral principles in the face of external pressures.

• The theme of justice is intimately connected to the corrosive influence of wealth. Claire's immense wealth becomes a tool that she wields to manipulate and test the moral fabric of the town. The townspeople's willingness to abandon their ethical standards for financial gain highlights the seductive power of wealth and its potential to corrupt moral judgment.

• The play explores the tension between individual moral responsibility and societal values. As the townspeople collectively grapple with Claire's offer, their actions highlight the challenging interplay between personal ethics and societal expectations. The unfolding events underscore the idea that individuals may succumb to collective pressure, compromising their morality for the perceived greater good of the community.

• "Der Besuch der alten Dame" delves into the consequences of individual and collective choices. The moral decisions made by characters have far-reaching implications, shaping the destiny of the town and its inhabitants. The play serves as a cautionary tale about the enduring impact of moral compromise and the inescapable consequences that follow such choices.

• Justice and morality become a lens through which the play reflects on human nature. The characters' responses to Claire's offer reveal the depths of human greed, desperation, and vulnerability to external influences. The narrative invites the audience to contemplate the complexities of human behaviour and the malleability of moral principles in challenging circumstances.

• Dürrenmatt employs absurdity and irony to underscore the themes of justice and morality. The absurd nature of Claire's revenge plan and the ironic twists in the townspeople's decisions add layers of complexity to the exploration of these themes, challenging traditional expectations and prompting the audience to reflect on the inherent contradictions in human behaviour.

Der Besuch der alten Dame" intricately weaves together themes of justice and morality, inviting the audience to contemplate the complexities of ethical decision-making in the face of external pressures. The play serves as a provocative exploration of human nature, societal values, and the consequences of moral compromise, challenging traditional notions of justice and morality in the context of a morally ambiguous and financially desperate society.

Let's now turn to vengeance. Claire's pursuit of vengeance is a driving force in the play. The narrative explores the lengths to which an individual might go to seek retribution for past wrongs. Claire's transformation into a figure of revenge highlights the destructive power of harbouring resentment.

• A prominent theme in the play is the power of wealth to shape decisions and actions. Claire Zachanassian's substantial fortune holds the town of Güllen in its grip, influencing the behaviour and choices of its residents. The promise of financial gain becomes a potent force, steering the moral compass of individuals and the collective community.

• The economic desperation of the town sets the stage for the transformative impact of wealth. Güllen's impoverished state renders its residents vulnerable to the seductive power of Claire's money. The prospect of escaping financial hardship becomes a compelling motivator, overshadowing ethical considerations.

• Claire masterfully wields her wealth as a tool of manipulation. Her ability to exploit the financial vulnerabilities of the townspeople underscores the immense power that wealth affords. Claire's offer becomes a form of economic coercion, revealing the extent to which financial incentives can override moral principles.

• The infusion of wealth fundamentally transforms Güllen. Initially portrayed as a struggling community, the town undergoes a radical metamorphosis in response to Claire's offer. The power of wealth reshapes the town's dynamics, leading to moral compromise, betrayal, and a pervading sense of opportunism.

• The townspeople grapple with a moral dilemma fuelled by the power of wealth. Each individual must weigh the financial benefits against the ethical consequences of their actions. The play highlights the internal conflicts faced by characters like Alfred Ill, torn between financial gain and moral integrity.

• Claire return symbolises the external influence that wealth can exert on a community. Her arrival is not merely personal but represents a larger force that disrupts the town's equilibrium. The power dynamics shift as Claire's wealth becomes a transformative agent, exposing the town's vulnerability.

• The theme of the power of wealth extends to its corrupting influence. The once-virtuous townspeople succumb to the allure of financial prosperity, abandoning ethical principles in the process. The play underscores how wealth, when wielded strategically, has the potential to corrupt individuals and societal values.

• Dürrenmatt employs irony and absurdity to emphasise the paradoxical nature of the power of wealth. The very wealth offered as a solution to the town's problems becomes the source of its moral degradation. The absurdity of the townspeople's actions in pursuit of wealth adds layers of complexity to the theme.

• The play serves as a critique of societal priorities, questioning the values that place financial gain above ethical considerations. Dürrenmatt invites the audience to reflect on the consequences of prioritising wealth at the expense of moral integrity and the potential erosion of communal bonds.

The play explores the transformative and often destructive power of wealth, illustrating how financial incentives can sway individual and collective decisions. It underscores the moral challenges posed by economic desperation and the seductive influence of prosperity, offering a nuanced commentary on the complexities of human behaviour in the face of financial temptation.

The Corrupting Influence of Wealth

One of the play’s clearest lessons is that wealth has a terrible power to corrupt individuals and communities. Claire’s billion-dollar temptation acts like a catalyst that reveals the Gülleners’ true values. In the beginning, the townsfolk appear honest and poverty-proud, but the mere prospect of money steadily erodes their integrity. Dürrenmatt illustrates this corruption subtly at first – through the appearance of new possessions (those gelben Schuhe and other goods) – and later overtly, as even authority figures rationalise killing in Ill. The teacher’s confession sums up the town’s moral degradation that everyone is turning into murderers for the sake of wealth.

Claire herself embodies the ambiguous role of wealth: she uses her riches as a weapon to exact revenge and also as a twisted form of social experiment, testing whether the townspeople can uphold their principles. The result is clear: virtually everything and everyone is for sale. The Mayor, who once extolled humanist values, ends up effectively condemning Ill. The policeman and priest, who should represent law and morality, both abandon Ill in favour of the town’s “higher” economic cause. Even Ill’s own family buys expensive items on credit, a silent signal that they accept his fate for a payout. Dürrenmatt’s portrayal is a scathing critique of materialism – he suggests that lofty ideals (religion, law, family loyalty) may crumble when confronted with the seductive power of money.

The play remains powerfully relevant as a commentary on how financial desperation can lead to moral compromise. In today’s world, we still see cases where economic incentives overpower ethical judgment (for example, corporations influencing communities, or injustice being tolerated in exchange for investment). Güllen’s situation – dire poverty making a community susceptible to bribery – reflects a universal truth about human societies. As one critic notes, the citizens’ rationalisation of unethical behaviour “for economic gain” is a phenomenon not limited to fiction. Der Besuch der alten Dame thus serves as a cautionary tale: “Geld regiert die Welt” (money rules the world), and when it does, moral values are at risk. The key message is to be wary of how quickly greed can nullify justice and decency.

Dürrenmatt explores the corrosive effects of wealth on individuals and society. Claire's vast wealth becomes a tool of manipulation, exposing the greed and moral compromise of the townspeople as they weigh the value of human life against financial prosperity.

Tip: Explore how wealth is portrayed as a corrupting force, influencing characters' decisions and the overall moral fabric of the town. To that end, consider the following points.

• Another important theme in "Der Besuch der alten Dame" is the corrupting influence of wealth. Claire's immense fortune becomes a catalyst for moral decay and societal deterioration in the town of Güllen. The play explores how the promise of financial prosperity can lead individuals and the community as a whole to compromise their moral principles.

• Claire uses her wealth strategically to manipulate the townspeople. The allure of financial gain seduces the impoverished residents, tempting them to abandon their ethical standards. Claire's ability to exploit their vulnerabilities underscores the corrupting power of wealth, turning individuals against each other and eroding the town's moral fabric.

• As the townspeople succumb to the promise of Claire's money, the play portrays a gradual moral decay. The once-virtuous citizens compromise their values in exchange for material wealth. This corrosion is evident in the decisions made by individuals, including Alfred Ill, who find themselves entangled in a web of moral compromise driven by financial desperation.

• Claire's offer to the town is a stark illustration of the idea that justice can be commodified. The townspeople, faced with economic hardship, are willing to sacrifice justice for personal gain. The play raises questions about the integrity of justice when it becomes a transaction, emphasising how wealth can distort and pervert the very notion of what is morally right.

• Claire's wealth is symbolic not only of financial power but also of external influence. Her return to Güllen represents the intrusion of external forces into the lives of the townspeople. The wealth she brings acts as a corrosive agent, exposing the vulnerabilities and moral weaknesses of the community.

• Dürrenmatt uses the theme to critique materialism and the prioritisation of financial gain over ethical considerations. The play serves as a commentary on a society willing to compromise its values for the pursuit of affluence, highlighting the dangers of placing material wealth above moral integrity.

• The play employs irony and absurdity to underscore the corrupting nature of wealth. The absurdity of Claire's revenge plan and the irony in the townspeople's actions add layers of complexity to the theme. The very wealth promised as a solution to the town's problems becomes the catalyst for its moral downfall.

• While set in a specific post-war German context, the theme of the corruption of wealth has universal resonance. Dürrenmatt's exploration of how financial desperation can lead to moral compromise speaks to broader societal issues and the potential pitfalls of prioritising wealth over ethical considerations.

The corruption of wealth in "Der Besuch der alten Dame" serves as a powerful and cautionary theme, highlighting the moral compromises and societal decay that can result from the seductive allure of financial prosperity. Dürrenmatt's exploration of this theme contributes to the play's enduring relevance and its capacity to prompt reflection on the ethical challenges posed by the influence of wealth in various societal contexts.

Tragicomedy: Blending Tragedy with Dark Comedy

Dürrenmatt subtitled the play a “tragische Komödie” (tragic comedy), and indeed the genius of Der Besuch der alten Dame lies in its fusion of the comic and the tragic. This blend makes the play’s grim message more palatable and striking. On the surface, many elements are exaggerated to the point of absurd, eliciting nervous laughter: Claire’s absurd entourage (including husbands numbered VII, VIII, and IX coming and going, and her two eunuchs Koby and Loby), the townspeople spouting lofty quotes and behaving with over-the-top civility even as they plot murder, and the bizarre grotesque touches (like Claire’s prosthetic leg and ivory hand, or the coffin she brings for Ill). These touches of dark humor and satire highlight the hypocrisy and absurdity of the situation. For example, it is grimly funny and ironic that Güllen holds a festive reception for Claire and names a new pavilion after her, all while inching toward collective homicide.

Yet beneath the comedic veneer, the play carries the weight of true tragedy. Claire’s story is tragic – a woman destroyed by betrayal, returning as a monstrous avenger. Ill’s story is tragic – a man essentially facing a death sentence that creeps ever closer as everyone he trusts turns away. The town’s story is tragic too – a moral downfall of an entire community. Dürrenmatt believed that in the modern world, classical tragedy (with a single noble hero) was no longer fully possible; instead, tragedy had to be intertwined with the grotesque and the absurd to reflect reality. In Der Besuch der alten Dame, he achieves this by making us both laugh at and be appalled by the people of Güllen.

For A-level students analysing the play, it’s important to note how comedy serves a critical purpose. The humour is very dark and often ironic. For instance, when asked if the play is a tragedy or a comedy, one could argue it’s both. The Mayor’s high-minded speeches in Act I are comedic in their pompousness, but by Act III those same words come back with a tragic irony (the town does become “blutbefleckt” – bloodstained). The townspeople’s cheery veneer (“We’ll stay poor but honourable”) turns into a macabre joke as they proceed to do the opposite. By mixing laughter with despair, Dürrenmatt prevents the play from becoming moralistic melodrama; instead, he engages the audience to reflect on the absurd contradictions in human behaviour. The key message here is that life can be simultaneously ridiculous and horrifying, and Der Besuch der alten Dame brilliantly captures that duality.

The play skilfully blends tragic elements with comedic undertones. The absurdity of the situation, coupled with the townspeople's reactions, creates a darkly humorous atmosphere. Yet, underlying the laughter is a deep sense of tragedy, especially as the play unfolds and the consequences of the townspeople's decisions become apparent.

Tip: Discuss the blending of tragic and comedic elements in the play, emphasising the absurdity of the situation and its underlying tragic consequences.

Tragic Elements

Fateful Retribution

• The play exhibits elements of classical tragedy in its portrayal of fateful retribution. Claire's return to the town is marked by a sense of inevitability and impending doom. The townspeople, particularly Alfred Ill, are ensnared in a web of circumstances that lead to tragic consequences.

Moral Dilemmas and Consequences

• The moral dilemmas faced by the characters contribute to the tragic dimension of the play. The townspeople grapple with the weight of their decisions, and the consequences of their choices unfold in a way that aligns with the inevitability characteristic of tragic narratives.

Societal Critique

• "Der Besuch der alten Dame" serves as a critique of societal values and the corrosive impact of wealth on morality. This critique, combined with the characters' moral compromises, contributes to the tragic vision of a society grappling with its own ethical decay.

Comic Elements

Dark Humour and Satire

• The play incorporates dark humour and satire, challenging the traditional seriousness associated with tragedy. The absurdity of the townspeople's decisions, particularly their willingness to sacrifice moral principles for financial gain, elicits moments of comedic reflection.

Exaggeration and Irony

• The exaggerated nature of Claire's revenge plan and the irony surrounding the townspeople's reactions introduce comedic elements. The play's use of irony prompts the audience to reflect on the absurdity of the situation, creating moments of dark comedy.

Cynical Commentary

• Dürrenmatt's cynical commentary on human nature, justice, and morality adds a comedic layer. The play invites the audience to laugh at the characters' foibles and the absurdity of their predicament, creating a satirical atmosphere that is characteristic of comedy.

The play is a blend of tragic and comedic elements that challenge the audience's expectations. It intertwines moral dilemmas, fateful retribution, and societal critique with dark humour, satire, and irony. This results in a thought-provoking tragicomedy that prompts reflection on human behaviour and moral compromise. The play's multi-layered nature and ambiguous aspects contribute to its enduring impact, engaging audiences in diverse ways and defying easy classification within a single dramatic genre.

Symbolism and Imagery

Dürrenmatt reinforces his themes through potent symbols and motifs:

• The Black Panther: Claire’s panther is a living symbol of her revenge. She brings it caged to Güllen and at one point releases it. The panther’s eventual shooting by the townsmen foreshadows Alfred Ill’s demise – like the panther, Ill is hunted as prey and ultimately killed. The panther’s presence also underscores Claire’s predatory nature (she is the huntress, Ill the hunted) and the idea that something wild and dangerous has been unleashed upon the town.

• Claire’s Prosthetic Limbs: Claire’s artificial leg and hand (the results of past accidents) are symbolic of how money and vengeance have made her somewhat inhuman or mechanical in her pursuits. They hint that she has lost and replaced parts of herself – a figurative loss of humanity and empathy – making her a “machine” driven by a single goal.

• Yellow Shoes and New Purchases: The townspeople’s new yellow shoes and other items bought on credit are visual metaphors for their corruption. The bright color literally marks their feet as walking the path of greed and violence. This imagery communicates on stage what no one will say aloud – that they all intend to kill Ill for the money.

• The Town Name – Güllen: The name Güllen, meaning “slurry” or manure, is itself a satirical symbol. It suggests that beneath the town’s outward claims to culture and humanism, there is moral rot. By the play’s end, this becomes clear: the noble surface gives way to a corrupt, “filthy” deed.

• Allusions to Ancient Tragedy: Dürrenmatt infuses the play with echoes of classical tragedy. Claire’s role as an implacable avenger has been compared to the figure of Medea (whom the teacher explicitly mentions). The final scene employs a chorus-like effect with the reporters and townspeople narrating Ill’s death, reminiscent of a Greek chorus delivering a fate. These allusions reinforce the sense of inescapable fate: from the moment Claire arrives, Ill’s end feels eerily inevitable – as if decreed by forces larger than himself (in this case, the force of greed and collective guilt).

Through these symbols and references, Der Besuch der alten Dame adds depth to its narrative and amplifies its themes. Recognising and analysing such imagery will strengthen your understanding and make your exam essays more insightful.

Tip: Dürrenmatt masterfully deploys symbolism and imagery to convey his messages. Here are some prime examples and tips for your analysis.

The Clock

• Analyse the symbolic significance of the clock in the town square, representing the countdown to moral judgment and the irreversible nature of time.

Claire's Artificial Limbs

• Explore the symbolism of Claire's artificial limbs as a physical manifestation of her past suffering and a reminder of the consequences of the townspeople's actions.

The Panther

The panther serves as a powerful metaphor, adding depth to the themes of vengeance, justice, and the corrupting influence of wealth.

Symbol of both Claire and Ill

• The panther is closely associated with Claire Zachanassian, the wealthy and vengeful protagonist of the play. It serves as a living symbol of Claire's formidable and predatory presence. However, the panther is also a potent symbol of Ill's fate and the destructive power of vengeance. Just as the panther, once a powerful and majestic creature, is captured and eventually killed after being released in the town, Ill, too, is a once-respected man who becomes trapped by the townspeople's greed and Claire Zachanassian's revenge. The panther's demise foreshadows Ill's own inescapable fate, symbolising how he is hunted and ultimately sacrificed to satisfy the town's desires. The panther, like Ill, is a victim of forces beyond its control, highlighting the themes of justice, corruption, and the moral decay of society.

Metaphor for Vengeance

• The panther is introduced as a gift from Claire to Güllen. This gesture is symbolic of Claire's predatory intent to hunt down and seek vengeance on Alfred Ill, the man who wronged her in the past. The panther becomes an instrument of her retribution, embodying the predatory nature of her quest for justice.

The Town's Acceptance of the Panther

• The fact that the townspeople accept the panther is indicative of their willingness to embrace Claire's wealth, regardless of the potential consequences. It reflects how the allure of financial gain can blind individuals to the moral implications of their actions. The panther becomes a tangible manifestation of the town's moral compromise.

The Corrupting Influence of Wealth

• The presence of the panther symbolises the corrupting influence of wealth on Güllen. Claire's offer of prosperity is accompanied by the introduction of the panther, and the town's embrace of both underscores the extent to which financial incentives can lead to moral decay. The panther becomes a living metaphor for the erosion of ethical standards.

Metaphysical Element

• The panther also introduces a metaphysical and surreal element into the narrative. Its presence in the town square, along with Claire's calculated revenge plan, adds to the overall absurdity of the situation. This blending of the real and the symbolic contributes to the tragicomic tone of the play.

Irony in the Panther's Role

• The irony lies in the dual nature of the panther – simultaneously a symbol of power and revenge, and a creature that can be manipulated. The townspeople initially view the panther as a status symbol, unaware of its true significance. This irony highlights the unsuspecting nature of the characters in the face of impending tragedy.

Foreshadowing and Inevitability

• The panther serves as a foreshadowing device, hinting at the inevitable consequences of Claire's visit. Its presence suggests that something predatory and destructive is unleashed upon the town. The panther becomes a harbinger of the moral reckoning that Güllen will face as a result of Claire's vengeance.

Claire's Transformation

• As the panther is symbolic of Claire's power, its presence mirrors Claire's own transformation from a victim of injustice to a powerful and vengeful force. Just as the panther embodies strength and predatory instincts, Claire emerges as a formidable figure capable of reshaping the destiny of the town.

The panther serves as a potent and multi-layered symbol that enriches the play's exploration of vengeance, justice, and the consequences of moral compromise. Its inclusion adds a surreal and metaphysical dimension to the narrative, contributing to the overall complexity and impact of Dürrenmatt's tragicomic examination of human behaviour and societal values.

Contemporary Relevance

Although Der Besuch der alten Dame was written in the 1950s, its messages resonate strongly today. The play addresses moral compromise, justice, and greed – issues that are timeless and universally human. In an era of glaring economic inequalities and debates about ethical leadership, Dürrenmatt’s dark satire feels quite modern. For example, the idea of a wealthy individual exerting outsized influence over a struggling community has parallels in contemporary society (consider how corporate money or billionaire donors can sway community decisions or justice systems). The Gülleners’ rationalisation of their crime (“we did it for the town’s prosperity”) is similar to how people today might justify unethical actions for the sake of profit or success.

The play also serves as a warning about collective responsibility and complicity. It asks us to consider how entire communities can be drawn into wrongdoing, a question as relevant now as in post-war Europe when the play premiered. The theme of “collective guilt” – that a whole society shares blame for allowing injustice – has contemporary echoes in discussions about the bystander effect, “cancel culture and public shaming” (modern forms of communal judgment), and social justice movements. In Der Besuch der alten Dame, every citizen’s silence and quiet compliance enable the atrocity, reminding modern audiences that evil triumphs not just through lone villains, but through the passive consent of many.

Perhaps the most enduring lesson from Güllen’s saga is the danger of exchanging humanity for prosperity. As one modern commentator noted, the play endures because it confronts us with “uncomfortable questions about human nature and moral compromise”, delivered with a mix of dark humour and moral inquiry. In a world where moral choices are often entangled with financial or political pressures, Der Besuch der alten Dame remains a sharply relevant parable. Its brilliant combination of entertainment and ethical confrontation means that in an era of increasing wealth inequality and moral relativity, its message resonates more strongly than ever. The conclusion leaves us uneasy: the town gains material wealth but loses its moral soul. This outcome prompts the question – what would we do in their place? The play offers no easy answers, but it challenges each generation of readers to reflect on the price of justice, the weight of guilt, and the true cost of a prosperity built on blood.

Theatrical and Other Influences

While Dürrenmatt drew inspiration from various sources, the play exhibits a unique synthesis of dramatic elements, philosophical themes, and historical context that contribute to its enduring significance.

Greek Tragedy

• Dürrenmatt's engagement with Greek tragedy is evident in "Der Besuch der alten Dame." The play echoes the classical structure of tragedy, featuring a tragic hero (Alfred Ill) and a pervasive sense of inevitability. The presence of a vengeful figure, Claire Zachanassian, resonates with the Greek motif of divine retribution, reminiscent of tragic figures seeking justice for perceived wrongs.

• The use of theatrical elements, such as the symbolic clock in the town square, reflects a nod to traditional theatrical devices. The clock acts as a ticking countdown, heightening tension and creating a sense of impending doom, a technique reminiscent of classical dramatic conventions.

Klotho- The Spinner of Fate

Reference in the Play

• Klotho is one of the three Moirai or Fates in Greek mythology, responsible for spinning the thread of human destiny. In the play, Claire Zachanassian is referred to as "Klotho," linking her character to the idea of controlling fate.

Significance

• The reference to Klotho highlights Claire's role as a manipulator of destinies. Claire, with her immense wealth and vengeful agenda, holds the power to shape the fate of individuals in Güllen. The townspeople become entangled in the metaphorical threads she spins, and their destinies are inexorably altered by her presence.

Symbolism

• The symbolism of Klotho underscores the deterministic nature of the unfolding events. The townspeople, much like characters in Greek tragedy, find themselves caught in a web of fate, manipulated by external forces beyond their control.

Medea -The Tragic Vengeful Figure

Reference in the Play

• Medea, a character from Greek mythology, is known for her vengeful acts, particularly the murder of her own children as an act of revenge against her unfaithful husband. In the play, Claire Zachanassian is likened to Medea, drawing parallels between the two figures.

Significance

• The reference to Medea serves to deepen the understanding of Claire's character. Just as Medea sought vengeance for personal betrayal, Claire's quest for justice is intertwined with a desire for retribution. This comparison adds a layer of tragic inevitability to Claire's actions, emphasising the destructive consequences of unresolved grievances.

Tragic Elements

• Medea's story is a classic tragedy, and by aligning Claire with this archetype, Dürrenmatt underscores the tragic dimensions of her character. The play becomes a modern-day tragedy in which the consequences of past actions come to fruition, echoing the themes of vengeance and tragedy found in Greek drama.

The Intersection of Myth and Reality

• The references to Klotho and Medea contribute to the blending of myth and reality in the play. Dürrenmatt creates a theatrical landscape where classical mythology intersects with the post-war, small-town setting. This blending enhances the play's universal themes, emphasising the timeless nature of human struggles with justice, revenge, and morality.

Irony and Tragicomedy

• The use of these classical references introduces irony and tragicomic elements into the narrative. While the allusions to Klotho and Medea evoke a sense of classical tragedy, the absurd and ironic twists in the plot bring a contemporary and comedic dimension to the play. This juxtaposition reinforces Dürrenmatt's exploration of the absurdity inherent in human behaviour and societal values.

The references to Klotho and Medea in "Der Besuch der alten Dame" serve as literary devices that enrich the play's thematic depth. These allusions provide insight into Claire Zachanassian's character, framing her as a figure with the power to control fate and drawing parallels with classical tragic figures. The interplay between myth and reality adds complexity to the narrative, contributing to the overall tragicomic tone of the play.

Existentialist Philosophical Influence

Dürrenmatt's exploration of existentialist themes aligns with the works of philosophers like Jean-Paul Sartre and Albert Camus. The characters in "Der Besuch der alten Dame" grapple with the consequences of their actions, embodying existentialist notions of personal responsibility and the search for meaning in a seemingly indifferent universe. Claire Zachanassian, with her wealth and pursuit of justice, mirrors existentialist themes of individual agency and the consequences of choice. The play challenges the characters and the audience to confront the existential dilemma of navigating moral choices in the face of external pressures.

Shakespearean Tragedy and Moral Complexity

The moral complexity in "Der Besuch der alten Dame" reflects a Shakespearean influence. Like Shakespearean tragedies, Dürrenmatt presents characters with moral dilemmas that transcend simple categorisations of right or wrong. The townspeople, torn between financial gain and moral integrity, embody the intricate moral landscapes found in Shakespeare's works. The play's exploration of revenge and its consequences echoes themes from Shakespearean tragedies such as "Hamlet" or "Othello," where characters grapple with the repercussions of their actions and the blurred lines between justice and vengeance.

Expressionist and Modernist Elements

Dürrenmatt incorporates expressionist and modernist elements into his play, aligning with the broader artistic movements of the 20th century. The play's symbolic and surreal aspects, such as Claire's artificial limbs and the town's transformation, reflect the influence of expressionism, a movement characterised by distorted reality and symbolic representation. The play's critique of societal values and the impact of external forces on individual lives aligns with modernist concerns. Dürrenmatt engages with the disillusionment and scepticism characteristic of modernist literature, challenging conventional notions of justice and morality.

Language and Style

Dürrenmatt employs a distinct style and language choices that contribute to the play's dramatic impact and its engagement with existential and absurd elements.

Tips: Discuss the use of theatrical techniques such as irony, dialogue, and monologues to convey the play's themes and engage the audience. Analyse how the setting, particularly the small-town atmosphere, contributes to the play's mood and impacts on the characters' decisions.

Here are key aspects of the language and style in "Der Besuch der alten Dame":

Theatrical Structure

• Dürrenmatt employs a well-crafted theatrical structure that enhances the play's dramatic impact. The use of three acts, each with its own developments and revelations, contributes to the pacing of the narrative and the building of tension.

Concise and Poetic Dialogue

• The dialogue in the play is concise and often takes on a poetic quality. Dürrenmatt uses language to convey deep emotions, complex moral dilemmas, and existential reflections. The dialogue serves as a vehicle for exploring profound themes while maintaining a sense of theatricality.

Tragicomic Tone

• The language and style contribute to the play's tragicomic tone. Dürrenmatt blends elements of tragedy and comedy to create a unique atmosphere. The absurdity of the townspeople's actions, the irony of their decisions, and the overall sense of inevitability are communicated through a style that balances seriousness and humour.

Existential Elements

• Dürrenmatt's language incorporates existentialist elements, reflecting the philosophical concerns of the time. The characters grapple with questions of individual responsibility, the consequences of past actions, and the nature of justice. The existential undertones add depth to the language and contribute to the intellectual complexity of the play.

Symbolism and Metaphor

• The language is rich in symbolism and metaphor. The panther, for example, serves as a powerful metaphor for Claire Zachanassian's revenge and the corrupting influence of wealth. Symbolic elements are woven into the dialogue, enhancing the play's allegorical dimensions.

Irony and Satire

• Dürrenmatt employs irony and satire to critique societal values, morality, and the impact of external pressures. The townspeople's initial rejection of Claire's offer and subsequent moral compromise are tinged with irony, highlighting the absurdity of human behaviour.

Economic and Social Commentary

• Language is used to provide economic and social commentary. The economic struggles of Güllen, the impact of Claire's wealth on the town, and the townspeople's willingness to sacrifice morality for prosperity are conveyed through the characters' interactions and the dialogue.

Monologues and Reflections

• The play includes monologues and reflective moments that allow characters to express their inner thoughts and conflicts. These soliloquies contribute to the psychological depth of the characters and provide insights into their motivations, adding layers to the narrative.

Satirical Elements

• Dürrenmatt's satirical style is evident in the portrayal of the townspeople and their collective decision-making. The exaggerated reactions, the absurdity of their choices, and the ultimate tragic consequences are presented with a satirical lens that prompts reflection on human folly.

Repetition as a Stylistic Device

• Repetition is used as a stylistic device, emphasising key themes and motifs. The recurring motif of Claire's offer and the townspeople's responses adds a rhythmic quality to the play, reinforcing the inevitability of the unfolding events.

In summary, the language and style in "Der Besuch der alten Dame" contribute to its theatrical impact and thematic richness. Dürrenmatt's use of concise yet poetic dialogue, existential elements, symbolism, and satirical tones creates a layered and thought-provoking theatrical experience. The play's linguistic choices enhance its exploration of profound philosophical questions within the framework of a tragicomic narrative.

Historical and Cultural Context

The play was written and premiered in the mid-1950s, a period marked by significant historical and social developments. Understanding the historical context helps illuminate some of the themes and motivations in the play.

Tips: Understand the historical context of post-war Germany and how it influences the characters' behaviours and attitudes. Explore the Cold War symbolism in the play, considering Claire's wealth as a representation of external influence and the town as a microcosm of broader societal issues.

Here are some key aspects worth considering:

Post-World War II Europe

• The play is set in a small, economically struggling town in post-World War II Europe. The aftermath of the war had profound effects on European societies, with many facing economic hardship, reconstruction challenges, and a reevaluation of societal values. The town's desperation for financial relief reflects the broader context of post-war recovery.

Switzerland in the 1950s

• Dürrenmatt, a Swiss playwright, wrote the play against the backdrop of Switzerland in the 1950s. Switzerland remained neutral during World War II, but the war's impact on neighbouring countries influenced Swiss society. The play critiques aspects of Swiss neutrality, societal norms, and economic disparities, using the fictional town of Güllen as a microcosm.

Cold War Tensions

• The 1950s were characterised by Cold War tensions between the Western bloc, led by the United States, and the Eastern bloc, led by the Soviet Union. While Switzerland was not directly involved in the Cold War conflicts, the global geopolitical atmosphere may have influenced Dürrenmatt's exploration of power dynamics, justice, and moral compromise.

Reevaluation of Values

• In the aftermath of World War II, there was a widespread reevaluation of societal values. The devastation of the war prompted reflections on morality, justice, and the consequences of unchecked power. "Der Besuch der alten Dame" engages with these themes, portraying a town forced to confront its own moral compromises in the face of financial temptation.

Economic Inequality and Corruption

• Economic inequality and corruption are central themes in the play. The post-war period witnessed economic disparities and a rebuilding phase that led to ethical dilemmas. Güllen's willingness to sacrifice morality for financial gain reflects broader societal challenges related to economic disparity and the pursuit of prosperity at any cost.

Understanding the historical context in which Dürrenmatt wrote "Der Besuch der alten Dame" provides insight into the societal and philosophical currents that influenced the play's themes and characters. The post-war era, with its economic challenges, moral reflections, and shifting geopolitical landscape, forms a backdrop against which the play's exploration of justice, revenge, and the corrupting influence of wealth unfolds.

Revision Exercises

Character Quotes

• Compile a list of key quotes for each major character and analyse their significance.

Theme Analysis

• Analyse the key themes and their development throughout the play.

Sample Essay Questions

• Würden Sie dieses Stück eher als eine Tragödie oder eine Komödie beschreiben? Begründen Sie Ihre Antwort.

• Wie behandelt Dürrenmatt das Thema der Gerechtigkeit in diesem Stück? Finden Sie diese Behandlung effektiv?

• Welche Bedeutung spielen Symbole im Stück?

• War der Tod von Ill unvermeidlich?

• Was macht das Stück so erfolgreich?

Essay Writing Tips

• Develop a clear but balanced answer to the essay question.

• To ensure that your essay is well-structured and argued write a clear introduction that highlights your answer to the essay question and briefly explains how you will make your case paragraph by paragraph.

• Emphasise the importance of supporting arguments with textual evidence, quoting relevant passages from the play.

• Summarise the main points in support of your argument in your conclusion.

• More tips on how to write an excellent A-level German essay can be found in my other post.

Typical A-level Questions on Der Besuch der alten Dame from past papers

1. Würden Sie dieses Stück eher als eine Tragödie oder eine Komödie beschreiben? Begründen Sie Ihre Antwort.

2. Inwiefern ist Ihrer Meinung nach der Tod von Alfred Ill unvermeidlich?

3. Auf welche Faktoren ist der Erfolg dieses Theaterstücks zurückzuführen? Begründen Sie Ihre Antwort.

4. Wie behandelt Dürrenmatt das Thema Gerechtigkeit in diesem Stück? Finden Sie diese Behandlung effektiv?

5. „Ich wollte das Publikum unterhalten, nicht belehren.” Inwiefern ist es Ihrer Meinung nach Dürrenmatt gelungen, dieses Ziel zu erreichen?

6. Welche Aspekte der Gesellschaft kritisiert Dürrenmatt in diesem Theaterstück? Begründen Sie Ihre Antwort.

7. Welche Rolle spielen Symbole in diesem Stück? Geben Sie Ihre Gründe an.

8. Wie effektiv finden Sie den Gebrauch von Farben und Symbolen in diesem Theaterstück? Geben Sie Gründe an.

9. „Die Versuchung ist zu groß und unsere Armut zu bitter." Von welcher Bedeutung sind Ihrer Meinung nach die Worte des Lehrers für dieses Theaterstück?

10. "Im Namen der Menschlichkeit...lieber bleiben wir arm denn blutbefleckt." Inwiefern drückt diese Aussage ein Hauptthema des Stücks aus.

11. „Obgleich es vom Tod eines Menschen handelt, gibt es viele komische Elemente im Stück.“ Analysieren Sie den Humor im Stück.

12. „Claire Zachanassian ist kein Mensch mehr; sie ist eine Maschine mit einem einzigen Ziel.“ Wie stehen Sie zu dieser Aussage?

13. „Eine kapitalistische Gesellschaft führt immer zum Verfall der Moral.“ Inwiefern stimmt diese Aussage Ihrer Meinung nach für das Hauptthema des Stücks?

14. Welche Rolle spielt das Groteske in diesem Theaterstück? Finden Sie den Gebrauch von grotesken Elementen effektiv? Begründen Sie Ihre Antwort.

15. Inwiefern spielen die Nebenfiguren eine bedeutende Rolle in dem Stück?

16. Erklären Sie den Grund für die schlechte wirtschaftliche Lage in Güllen. Analysieren Sie, wie die Verbesserung der Wirtschaft die Güllener beeinflusst.

17. Beschreiben Sie, warum das Thema Gerechtigkeit wichtig ist. Untersuchen Sie, wie Claire den Begriff versteht.

18. Erklären Sie den Grund für die Ankunft der Presse in Güllen. Analysieren Sie, wie die Medien präsentiert werden.

19. Beschreiben Sie, wie die Güllener Alfred Ills Flucht verhindern. Untersuchen Sie, wie Alfreds Fluchtversuch für ihn zu einem Wendepunkt wird.

20. Beschreiben Sie das Verhältnis zwischen Claire und Alfred. Analysieren Sie, wer von den beiden den stärkeren Charakter hat.

21. Beschreiben Sie, wie Dürrenmatt das Thema Schuld präsentiert. Untersuchen Sie, wer in dem Stück die größte Schuld trägt.

22. Beschreiben Sie Claires Aussehen. Untersuchen Sie, warum Dürrenmatt Claires Charakter durch ihr Aussehen darstellt.

23. Beschreiben Sie die Form dieses Stückes. Analysieren Sie, warum Dürrenmatt diese Form gewählt hat.

24. Beschreiben Sie die Rolle des schwarzen Panthers in diesem Stück. Beurteilen Sie, inwiefern der Panther ein erfolgreiches Symbol für den Charakter von Alfred Ill ist.

25. Beschreiben Sie den Inhalt des Schlusschors am Ende dieses Stückes. Analysieren Sie, was Dürrenmatt in dieser letzten Szene erreichen will.

26. Beschreiben Sie, wie der Lehrer auf Claire Zachanassians Besuch reagiert. Untersuchen Sie, inwieweit er eine Ausnahme unter den Güllenern ist.

27. Beschreiben Sie, wie Claire die Männer in ihrem Leben behandelt. Beurteilen Sie, ob man mit Claires Situation Mitleid haben kann.

28. Beschreiben Sie, welche Rolle das Geld in diesem Stück spielt. Untersuchen Sie, wie das Stück beweist, dass Geld „die Wurzel allen Übels“ ist.

29. Beschreiben Sie, warum der Konradsweilerwald für Claire und Ill wichtig ist. Analysieren Sie, wie Dürrenmatt diesen Ort zu einem wichtigen Symbol macht.

30. Beschreiben Sie die Rolle des Bürgermeisters in diesem Stück. Untersuchen Sie, inwiefern er ein typischer Güllener ist.

31. Erklären Sie die Bedeutung des Names Claire Zachanassian in diesm Stück. Analysieren Sie, was Dürrenmatt mit den Namen der anderen Personen in diesem Stück andeuten will.

32. Beschreiben Sie eine Schlüsselszene in diesem Werk. Analysieren Sie die Auswirkungen dieser Szene auf die Personen im Stück.

33. Beschreiben Sie, welche Mittel Claire benutzt, um ihr Ziel zu erreichen. Beurteilen Sie, inwiefern diese Mittel moralisch vertretbar sind.

34. Beschreiben Sie die Rolle der Güllener bei Ills Tod. Inwiefern ist diese Rolle überraschend für die Zuschauer?

35. Erklären Sie, warum dieses Stück als eine Komödie beschrieben wird. Analysieren Sie die Funktion der komischen Elemente.

36. ‚Der Besuch der alten Dame könnte auch heute stattfinden‘. Beurteilen Sie die Wichtigkeit des Kontexts in diesem Stück.

37. ‚Was sind wir für Menschen? Die schändliche Milliarde brennt in unseren Herzen.' (Der Lehrer) Beurteilen Sie die Wichtigkeit des Zitats für das Stück.

38. Analysieren Sie die Idee von Macht in diesem Stück.

39. Untersuchen Sie die Wichtigkeit der Bühnenanweisungen für das Werk.

40. Beurteilen Sie, inwieweit Claire ein Monster ist.

Exam Tips: Tackling Common Questions on Der Besuch der alten Dame

When preparing for A-level German essay questions on this play, remember to structure your answers clearly, use evidence (quotes) from the text, and address both sides of any argument. Below, we address three typical exam questions and suggest how to approach them coming from the above list.

1. “Würden Sie dieses Stück eher als eine Tragödie oder eine Komödie beschreiben? Begründen Sie Ihre Antwort.”(“Would you describe this play more as a tragedy or a comedy? Justify your answer.”)

• Recognise it’s a tragicomedy: In your response, acknowledge that Dürrenmatt deliberately merges elements of tragedy and comedy in this play. Explain that while the outcome and themes are tragic (Ill’s death, moral corruption), the presentation includes dark comedy and satire (grotesque characters, absurd situations). For instance, you could cite the absurd humour in the townspeople’s polite behaviour and Claire’s mordant one-liners, and contrast them with the underlying tragic events.

• Give examples of each: Describe at least one tragic aspect (e.g. Ill’s inevitable downfall resembling a fate in Greek tragedy, or Claire as a tragic figure warped by suffering) and one comedic aspect (e.g. the ironic gap between the town’s pretensions and their actions, or Claire’s over-the-top entourage which adds dark humor). Using specific examples shows the examiner you understand both tones in the play.

• Address Dürrenmatt’s intent: Mention that Dürrenmatt himself labelled the play a tragic comedy, signalling that it cannot be neatly classified as one or the other. He believed modern life defies pure tragedy; instead, he used comedy to provoke thought (“Ich wollte das Publikum unterhalten, nicht belehren” – “I wanted to entertain the audience, not lecture them,” he said elsewhere). This intent is reflected in the play’s mix of horrifying subject matter with satirical presentation.

• Conclusion: A strong answer will conclude that Der Besuch der alten Dame is both comic and tragic. You may argue which element you find more dominant, but emphasise that the combination is what gives the play its unique power. Support your stance with a clear justification and evidence.

2. “Inwiefern ist Ihrer Meinung nach der Tod von Alfred Ill unvermeidlich?”(“To what extent, in your opinion, is the death of Alfred Ill unavoidable (inevitable)?”)

• Discuss foreshadowing and fate: Point out the numerous hints Dürrenmatt gives that Ill’s death is fated from early on. The town’s name (Güllen) and its desperate condition foreshadow moral decay, Claire’s ominous “Ich warte” implies she is certain the town will comply, and the killing of the black panther suggests a direct parallel to Ill’s end. All these elements create a sense of inevitability and zugeschlagenes Schicksal (a sealed fate) for Ill.

• Role of free will: On the other hand, consider if anything could have changed. Was there a moment when the townspeople (or Ill himself) could have averted this outcome? Perhaps initially, if the town had unanimously and steadfastly rejected the offer (as they claimed to in Act I), Ill might have lived. But Dürrenmatt constructs the story such that every pillar of support for Ill – law, family, religion, friendship – falls away one by one, suggesting a relentless march toward tragedy.

• Ill’s acceptance: Emphasise Ill’s own character arc. By Act III, Ill himself comes to believe his death is inevitable and openly resigns himself to it. His acceptance (“Ich kämpfe nicht mehr,” “I won’t fight anymore”) is key evidence that the character feels the outcome is fated. He even refuses to escape when given the chance, which underlines the idea that destiny (or his own guilt) has caught up with him.

• Your judgment with evidence: In conclusion, state how inevitable you think Ill’s death is, backing it up with evidence. A balanced answer might argue that Ill’s death appears almost inevitable given the forces at play – greed, peer pressure, Claire’s calculated manipulation, and even Ill’s sense of guilt. The structure resembles a classical tragedy where a flaw or past sin leads inexorably to downfall, which makes Ill’s end feel destined. However, you could note that it’s ultimately driven by human choices (the town could have chosen not to kill him), which adds nuance. A top-tier answer will acknowledge this tension between fate and free will.

4. “Wie behandelt Dürrenmatt das Thema Gerechtigkeit in diesem Stück? Finden Sie diese Behandlung effektiv?”(“How does Dürrenmatt treat the theme of justice in this play? Do you find this treatment effective?”)

• Explain Dürrenmatt’s portrayal of “justice”: Start by noting that the play presents justice in a highly ironic and critical way. Instead of true justice, we see vigilante justice (Claire’s personal revenge) carried out through a corrupt bargain. Claire calls it “Gerechtigkeit,” but it’s actually Rache (revenge). Use Claire’s words to illustrate this, for example her claim of buying justice for a billion and her chilling line equating the world to a brothel. This shows how she perverts the idea of justice to justify murder.

• Contrast real justice vs. false justice: Discuss how real justice (impartial law and moral fairness) failed in Claire’s youth – Ill escaped punishment through lies and bribery – and how she now subverts justice to serve her vendetta. The town’s initial stance (“you can’t buy justice”) represents conventional morality, whereas their later action (killing Ill for money) shows the concept of justice being twisted by self-interest. The play pointedly asks the audience to consider whether Ill’s death is justice served or justice perverted.

• Evaluate effectiveness: To assess whether this portrayal is effective, consider the emotional and intellectual impact on the audience. Dürrenmatt’s stark depiction of the townspeople rationalising a murder forces us to confront how easily justice can be compromised. This shock value is highly effective in conveying his warning. Also, note that the play doesn’t preach through heavy moral lectures; instead, it uses symbolism and irony to drive the point home. For instance, the town that once spoke of “humanity” ends up committing a heinous act – a dramatic demonstration of justice turned upside down, which leaves a strong impression.

• Personal response: You could mention whether, as a reader/viewer, you found Dürrenmatt’s treatment convincing. Many would agree it’s effective because it’s unsettling yet plausible – it challenges us to think about how money and desperation can subvert morality. The gruesome final “justice” delivered to Ill stands as the ultimate indictment of the town’s values, powerfully underscoring Dürrenmatt’s message that true justice is absent in this outcome.

• Wrap up: Conclude that Dürrenmatt handles the theme of justice by essentially showing its absence – highlighting hypocrisy, corruption, and revenge in its place – and that this dark portrayal is effective precisely because it shocks the audience into reflecting on their own principles and society’s integrity.

General Essay Tip: Regardless of the question, write a clear introduction that outlines your argument, develop each paragraph with specific evidence from the play (including German quotes, as we have done above) to support your points, and end with a concise conclusion. Showing awareness of both the play’s content and its literary techniques (such as irony, symbolism, and tragicomic tone) will demonstrate a thorough understanding. With a solid grasp of Der Besuch der alten Dame’s plot, characters, themes, and messages – as detailed in this guide – you will be well-equipped to write an excellent essay. Viel Erfolg bei der Prüfung! (Good luck with your exam!)

Dürrenmatt's skilful blending of tragedy and comedy, along with the exploration of characters caught in a web of revenge and moral compromise, contributes to the enduring relevance and impact of the play in the realm of dramatic literature. If you found this #revisionguide useful, please leave a like. All the best with your #AlevelGerman exam!

If you found this post helpful, please like and share it with others so that many students can benefit from it. Thank you.

📈 Want to achieve top marks in A-level German?

At Olesen Tuition, we help students secure A*/9 grades through a proven mix of:

• ✅ Weekly A-level German group classes

• ✅ 1:1 tuition (online or in person)

• ✅ Intensive revision courses

Taught by an Oxford-educated native tutor with a 95% A* track record. Ideal for both school-based and external candidates.

👉 See all A-level German lessons options

On our German language learning blog "Auf Deutsch, bitte!", you will also find an A-level German revision guide in der Vorleser, an A-level German revision on das Leben der Anderen and other helpful posts on how to get an A* in A-level German, such as German sentence structure, the rules on the four German cases, and German adjective endings.